Eggplant parmigiana…the one and only authentic “parm”.
Not chicken. Not veal. The dish they call “Parmigiana” in Italy is exclusively eggplant parmesan.
It’s unlikely you’ll find other variants there. Legend has it those were invented by Italians here in America. But you’ll find eggplant parm everywhere in Italy.
It’s so easy to make, but so easy to mess up at the same time. So, today I’m going to show you an eggplant parmigiana recipe that is foolproof. I think it is a real winner.
What's a real Eggplant Parmigiana?
As I was saying, the original Parmigiana is a baked dish made of eggplants layered with tomato/marinara sauce and grated cheese. It is also known as parmigiana di melanzane (“eggplant parmesan”).
It’s most common in the Southern part of Italy.
I’ve had some awesome eggplant parms in Sicily and the Naples area. They were so good that I took some notes to see if I could replicate them and serve them to our clients at Mortadella Head.
Now, I busted out the notebook for this post. So let’s see what we can do.
The ingredients are really simple!
You don’t need many ingredients to make a delicious eggplant parmigiana. Here they are.
Eggplants: Get nice firm Italian or Japanese eggplants.
Provolone cheese: Many people use mozzarella cheese. However, I think a nice mild provolone sliced at the deli counter is just perfect.
Romano cheese: Get a chunk of pecorino Romano and grate it yourself for the best results. Other people use parmesan cheese, but I think pecorino gives the best results. If you’re curious about the difference, check our article about pecorino romano vs. parmesan cheese.
Basil: Use fresh basil. It makes all the difference in the world.
Tomato Sauce: A good sauce is really important. Make a simple sauce yourself or use a really good store-bought tomato sauce. And if you want to make your parm as we serve it at our restaurant, you can use our Mortadella Head Marinara Sauce.
Frying oil: you will need this to fry your eggplant before baking them with the rest of the ingredients.
(Optional) Extra-Virgin Olive Oil: as you’ll see later, you’ll need to layer the ingredients in a baking dish. Many people like to add some extra-virgin olive oil before the first layer of tomato sauce. This is to prevent the eggplant parm from sticking to the dish.
You can find the ratio of the ingredients in the recipe card at the end of this post. I’ve put it there so that you can scale the ratio according to the number of servings with just one click. Try it out!
But first, let’s look at the baking process.
How to make baked eggplant parmigiana
Now, let’s see how to make your eggplant parmigiana step by step.
This is a very easy dish. It takes about 30 minutes to prepare the ingredients, and 40 minutes to bake everything. We’ll get to that in a moment.
Step 1: Let’s start by cutting off the ends of the eggplant and peeling off the skin. After that, you want to cut your eggplant the long way into ¼ thick slices.
Step 2: Heat some olive oil in a frying pan on medium to high heat.
In the meantime, flour and egg your eggplant slices. Arrange a station, put the ingredients on one plate each, and season them well with some pinch of salt and black pepper.
Now, let’s start with the flour, then with the egg.
Dredge each eggplant slice in the flour. Get both sides good. Press down a little to make it stick if you have to.
After that, shake off the excess flour and give your eggplant slice a good dunk in the eggs. Coat it completely and let any excess egg drip off.
Now repeat with the other slices, and remember to check the oil. You don’t want it to be too hot.
Step 3: Once the oil is ready, fry your eggplant slices for about a minute on each side. We’re looking for a gold brown color, like in the second picture below.
Step 4: When the eggplant is fried, it’s time to start layering.
First, let your eggplant slices dry a little on a plate covered with paper towels. Then take a baking dish, and start working your magic.
Avoid small baking sheets, and go for deeper bakeware. The more layers the better in my opinion.
Here’s the order of layering I suggest: start with tomato sauce, then add a single layer of eggplant slices, and then another layer of provolone cheese, trimmed fresh basil leaves, and grated pecorino Romano… and repeat.
In the meantime, preheat your oven to 400 degrees.
Keep going as high as you want. I like to finish off my last layer with some extra sauce and grated Romano cheese.
Step 5: Now pop your baking dish in the preheated oven and… BOOM! After 40 minutes at 400° F oven temperature, you’re ready to eat!
You can serve your eggplant parmigiana on a dish (like you would with a lasagna), or toss it on some bread and make an awesome parmigiana sandwich like we did for this tutorial.
What to serve with eggplant parmigiana
An awesome dish needs excellent food pairings. Here’s what you should have alongside your eggplant parm.
Wine: A glass of Nebbiolo is perfect for this dish.
Pasta: Serve your eggplant parmigiana with baked ziti.
Appetizers: I love room temperature eggplant parmigiana served alongside imported salami, cheese and marinated vegetables.
Can I fry the eggplant without the flour and eggs?
Yes. If you prefer to leave out the flour and/or eggs you’ll have a delicious gluten-free eggplant parmigiana.
Can I bake the eggplant instead of frying it?
You can brush the eggplant slices with olive oil and bake on a sheet pan at 400°F until they are browned.
Can I freeze my eggplant parmigiana?
Absolutely! Freezing is actually the best way to store eggplant parmigiana.
I usually make a bunch of ready-to-bake eggplant parm dishes at a time. I freeze them after I’m done layering the eggplant, sauce, and cheese. Then I just pop them in the oven when I’m ready to eat.
Are there any other recipes with a good substitute for eggplant?
Yes. Try using zucchini. Zucchini Parmigiana is delicious!
And if you don't feel like cooking today...
Now you have everything you need to make your own eggplant parmigiana at home. I hope you like it as much as I do.
If that’s the case, why don’t you let me know? Rate this recipe, or tell me what you think in the comments. I’ll be glad to exchange tips and ideas.
And if you are in Somerville, MA… did you know that you can have this and many other wonderful dishes catered to your home or office?
Order your eggplant parmigiana now, or grab your coat and come visit us! We’re waiting for you.